If you've applied for benefits through Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) or Supplemental Security Income (SSI) and have been denied, you're probably wondering whether it's worth it to appeal. We surveyed readers across the U.S. who applied for SSDI or SSI to find out about their experiences with the application and hearing process. Here's what we learned about the outcome of their claims at different stages in the process—in particular, what happened when they requested a hearing after their application was denied.
Our survey results supported what many people suspect—that it's difficult to get Social Security disability benefits. But it may surprise some people to see what a big difference it makes when applicants persist after an initial denial and follow through with the process.
Less than a quarter of our readers (23%) were approved for benefits at the initial application stage. The others were denied either because they didn't meet the work history and/or financial requirements (referred to as "technical denials") or because they didn't qualify medically for SSDI or SSI. But if you're denied for medical reasons, you can appeal by requesting a hearing in front of a judge (after first going through a reconsideration review).
Once our readers were able to present their evidence before a judge, nearly half of them (46%) won their case. That means they were twice as likely to be approved for benefits at the hearing level as at the initial application level. (Government statistics show similar approval rates at the hearing level in 2018, with a higher percentage of approvals when applicants were applying for SSDI only.)
There are several reasons why the chances of getting approved for disability benefits after a hearing are higher than at the initial application level. For one thing, it can be a while before the hearing takes place. During that time, many applicants' medical conditions get worse, making their cases stronger. (For example, multiple sclerosis and congestive heart failure, diseases which tend to get worse over time, have hearing approval rates of 80% and 78% respectively; see more about our survey results on disability approval rates for common medical conditions.)
The most important reason for the higher average approval rates at the hearing stage is likely that far more applicants hire lawyers at this point in the process. While only a third of our readers (33%) had an attorney's help with the initial application, nearly three-fourths (71%) had legal representation at the hearing. That decision more than doubled the chances of a good outcome: Half of our readers with legal representation (50%) were approved for benefits after the hearing, compared to less than a quarter (23%) of those who represented themselves. (Government statistics support this large advantage for applicants who are represented at the hearing stage.)
Meanwhile, readers who didn't get a lawyer's help were only slightly more likely to win benefits at the hearing stage than at the initial application.
One reason that applicants with legal representation fare better at the hearing stage has to do with how lawyers are paid to work on SSDI and SSI cases. Disability attorneys are almost always allowed to charge a fee only if they win benefits for their clients. Because of this "contingency fee" arrangement, lawyers generally have a screening process for potential clients; they're more likely to take cases that appear to have a decent chance of success.
There are several other reasons that having a lawyer makes such a big difference in the outcome of SSDI and SSI claims at the hearing stage. An experienced disability attorney can help you gather the right kind of medical evidence that will support your case. That includes knowing when your medical records need updating and when a medical expert would help. (It also means knowing where to find the right experts.) According to a government report, disability applicants were 1.6 times more likely to be approved for benefits than other applicants when a medical expert testified at the hearing. Because these medical professionals are there to give expert, impartial opinions, judges tend to value their testimony when making their decisions.
Given how much a hearing improves the chances of success in getting Social Security disability benefits, it may be surprising to learn how many applicants give up when they get that first denial letter. Only a little more than half of our readers requested a hearing after their initial application was denied.
It may be that many of the others realized they weren't likely to get benefits because their medical condition didn't fit the disability requirements. But it's also likely that many others were simply discouraged with the complicated, lengthy process. That's understandable. But an experienced disability lawyer can help you through that process, evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of your application, and prepare you for a hearing. (Learn more about what our survey showed about the difference a disability lawyer makes in SSI/SSDI claims, including how our readers felt about their attorneys.)