Should I Hire a Disability Lawyer or a Non-Attorney Advocate?

Since disability attorneys and nonattorney representatives can charge the same fees, it usually makes sense to hire a lawyer.

Talk to a Disability Lawyer

Enter Your Zip Code to Connect with a Lawyer Serving Your Area

Gavel and Scales

If you decide to hire someone to represent you at your Social Security disability hearing, you can choose either a disability attorney or a nonattorney advocate.

Generally, in both cases, the person you hire will not be paid unless you win your disability claim; likewise, both are paid directly by the Social Security Administration (SSA) out of your back payment benefits. Both attorneys and nonattorney advocates are entitled to the same fee amount for representing a disability applicant.

What Is the Difference Between an Attorney and Non-Attorney Advocate?

The biggest differences between an attorney and a non-attorney advocate (or representative) are their education levels and training.

Attorney. To become an attorney, an individual must have the following qualifications:

  • a bachelor’s degree (four-year college degree)
  • a juris doctorate (J.D.) degree (usually a three-year program of legal studies), and
  • admission to a state bar (which requires passing a rigorous bar exam).

Nonattorney advocate. The SSA has established the following requirements to get paid directly by Social Security for acting as a nonattorney representative/advocate:

  • a bachelor’s degree or “equivalent qualifications derived from training and work experience”
  • passage of a criminal background check
  • professional liability insurance
  • passage of a written exam administered by the SSA, and
  • completion of continuing education courses.

Pros of Hiring a Disability Attorney

When deciding whether to hire a disability lawyer versus a nonlawyer representative, you should consider the following pros of hiring a lawyer:

  • Attorneys are bound by professional conduct rules and ethical obligations to zealously represent their clients, while nonattorney representatives are not held to the same standard (but this does not mean they are unethical).
  • Attorney are bound to keep anything you tell them confidential due to the attorney-client privilege.
  • An attorney has many years of specialized training, which may better enable them to spot and resolve potential legal issues and to craft legal theories for reasons you should get benefits.
  • A non-attorney representative cannot appeal your claim to the federal district court level, and
  • You can file a complaint against an attorney through your state’s grievance commission if you feel your attorney did not act in your best interest; there is no such recourse with non-attorney representatives.

Cons of Hiring a General Practice Attorney

Attorneys can practice all types of law in the state where they are licensed, meaning an attorney might only dabble in disability law (but most lawyers who practice Social Security disability law specialize in disability). Non-attorney representatives have only disability clients, which means their knowledge is more focused that a general practice attorney. For these reasons, if you hire an attorney, make sure the attorney specializes in Social Security disability law, or disability law one or two other areas like workers' compensation or Medicare law (as long as the fields are closely related).

Some statistics show that attorneys have higher approval rates at the hearing level; however, these numbers are disputed by non-attorney representatives, who say that the statistics for nonlawyer representatives reflect hearings where the claimant is represented by a family member or other untrained individual.

It is important when choosing a representative (lawyer or nonlawyer) to know how many disability claims he or she wins at the ALJ hearing level. You should also ask how many claims the representative takes to the hearing level because law firms and nonattorney groups will frequently refuse to represent a disability claimant if they feel there is little chance of success. This is done to create better approval statistics.

Making Sure You're Hiring an Attorney

If it is important to you that your representative is a trained and licensed attorney, be sure to ask directly whether he or she is a member of the bar, because nonattorney representative firms can use misleading titles such as:

  • legal representative
  • claimant representative
  • disability representative, or
  • disability advocate.

While there is nothing inherently wrong with these titles, they can be confusing and, occasionally, misleading.

Finding a Local Disability Lawyer

If you've decided to hire a disability lawyer/attorney, you can use our lawyer locator to find an experienced disability lawyer in your area.

LA-NOLO5:DRU.1.6.3.6.20141124.29342